Why Your Negotiation Skills Are Probably Rubbish (And How To Fix Them)

Related Training Articles:

• Managing Difficult Conversations
• Customer Service Excellence Training

Right, let's get one thing straight from the start: most people think they're decent negotiators until they meet someone who actually knows what they're doing. Then they get absolutely schooled.

I remember watching a procurement manager at a major Perth mining company completely butcher what should have been a straightforward supplier negotiation. Instead of securing better terms, he ended up paying 15% more than the previous contract and somehow agreed to shorter payment terms. The supplier must have thought Christmas had come early.

The Problem With "Natural" Negotiators

Here's my first controversial opinion: being naturally persuasive doesn't make you a good negotiator. It makes you dangerous.

Natural persuaders often rely on charm and charisma, which works brilliantly until it doesn't. Real negotiation is about preparation, strategy, and understanding psychology. It's chess, not checkers.

I've seen too many smooth-talking sales directors crash and burn when they come up against properly trained procurement teams. These people eat charm for breakfast and spit out failed negotiations.

The Medibank Private team I worked with in Melbourne absolutely exemplified this difference. Their negotiation protocols were methodical, data-driven, and consistently delivered results that their "wing it" competitors couldn't touch.

Stop Treating Every Negotiation Like A Battle

Second controversial take: the whole "win-lose" mentality is outdated garbage that's costing Australian businesses millions every year.

I spent five years thinking negotiation was about crushing the other party. Scorched earth tactics. Make them beg. All that alpha nonsense you see in bad movies.

Wrong. Completely wrong.

The best negotiations I've witnessed – and I mean the ones that create long-term value – focus on expanding the pie before dividing it. When Woolworths negotiates with suppliers, they're not just beating them down on price. They're finding ways to reduce costs across the entire supply chain.

But here's where it gets interesting. Sometimes you DO need to be ruthless. When someone's trying to exploit your goodwill or testing your boundaries, being collaborative makes you a doormat.

Knowing when to switch between collaborative and competitive approaches? That's the real skill.

The Preparation Myth Everyone Believes

Here's where most negotiation training goes wrong: they tell you to prepare extensively. Research the other party. Know their pain points. Understand their alternatives.

All true. All important. All completely useless if you're preparing for the wrong conversation.

73% of failed negotiations happen because both parties were solving different problems. You're negotiating contract terms while they're negotiating relationship dynamics. You're focused on this quarter while they're planning next year.

I learned this the hard way during a software licensing negotiation in Sydney. Spent weeks researching their company financials, competitor pricing, implementation timelines. Walked in confident. Got destroyed.

Turns out they weren't buying software. They were buying a scapegoat for their failed digital transformation. Completely different negotiation.

The real preparation isn't about them. It's about understanding what conversation you're actually having.

Why Most People Negotiate Like Amateurs

Watch people negotiate and you'll notice something fascinating: they treat it like a performance instead of a process.

They rehearse dramatic pauses. Practice power poses. Memorise clever comebacks. Like they're auditioning for The Apprentice instead of trying to reach mutually beneficial outcomes.

Professional negotiators – the ones who actually get results – are boring. They ask questions. They listen. They take notes. They clarify understanding.

No theatrical nonsense. No psychological manipulation. Just systematic information gathering and option generation.

The Commonwealth Bank's commercial lending team operates exactly like this. Methodical, professional, surprisingly collaborative. And they consistently structure deals that other banks can't match because they understand the client's actual needs, not just their stated position.

The Email Negotiation Disaster

Can we please stop trying to negotiate complex deals via email? Please?

Email strips out 90% of communication value. No tone. No body language. No immediate clarification. Just words that can be misinterpreted six different ways.

Yet I see supposedly intelligent business people trying to hash out partnership agreements through email chains that would make a lawyer weep. Then they wonder why relationships sour and deals fall apart.

If it matters, pick up the phone. Better yet, meet in person. Or at minimum, use video calls where you can see facial expressions and reaction timing.

Exception: Using email to confirm agreements reached verbally. That's documentation, not negotiation.

The Small Business Negotiation Trap

Small business owners often make a critical error: they negotiate like they're still small when they're actually dealing with enterprise-level decisions.

Personal relationships matter in small business. But when you're negotiating six-figure contracts, professional processes matter more.

I watched a Brisbane-based logistics company lose a massive contract because the owner kept trying to negotiate on handshakes and "trust me" agreements. The enterprise client needed formal risk assessments, performance guarantees, and escalation procedures.

Different leagues require different playbooks.

Power Dynamics Nobody Talks About

Here's something most negotiation experts won't tell you: power imbalances aren't always what they seem.

The buyer doesn't always hold the cards. The bigger company isn't always stronger. The one with more options isn't always in control.

Real power comes from preparation, patience, and the willingness to walk away. I've seen sole traders negotiate better terms with major corporations than department heads managed internally because they understood their true value proposition.

Australian businesses need to stop assuming size equals strength in negotiations.

Actually, let me share something that still makes me cringe. Early in my career, I was negotiating office space in Adelaide's CBD. The property manager seemed intimidating – expensive suit, fancy office, constantly checking his phone like he had better things to do.

I accepted their first offer. Didn't even try to negotiate.

Found out later they'd been sitting empty for eight months and would have accepted 30% less. My intimidation cost the company thousands.

Power is often perception.

The Cultural Dimension

Australian business culture creates unique negotiation challenges. We value directness but also mateship. We appreciate honesty but also competitive advantage.

This creates fascinating dynamics. In Asia-Pacific negotiations, Australian directness can be perceived as aggressive. In American contexts, our collaborative approach can seem weak.

The Telstra international deals team handles this brilliantly by adapting their negotiation style to cultural context while maintaining core Australian values of fairness and straight talking.

Technology Is Changing Everything

Modern negotiation tools are game-changers that most Australian businesses haven't adopted yet.

Data analytics can predict negotiation outcomes. Video analysis can identify stress indicators. Digital platforms can facilitate complex multi-party negotiations with real-time option modelling.

Yet most businesses still negotiate like it's 1995. Handwritten notes, gut feelings, and "let me check with my boss" delays.

The companies that embrace these tools aren't just getting better deals. They're getting them faster and with less relationship damage.

Training That Actually Works

Forget role-playing scenarios with your colleagues. They know you too well and you all share the same organisational biases.

Real negotiation training involves structured practice with strangers, video review of actual performance, and systematic skill development across different negotiation types.

The Harvard Program on Negotiation approach works. So does the emotional intelligence training for managers methodology when applied to negotiation contexts.

Most importantly: practice difficult conversations regularly. Negotiation skills atrophy quickly without use.

The Bottom Line

Negotiation isn't an art. It's a learnable skill set with measurable outcomes.

Stop treating it like a mysterious talent some people have and others don't. Invest in proper training. Practice systematically. Measure results.

Your competitors probably aren't doing this. Which makes it a competitive advantage waiting to be claimed.

The question isn't whether you can afford negotiation training. It's whether you can afford not to have it.

Every business conversation is a negotiation. Every stakeholder interaction involves competing interests. Every successful outcome requires somebody who knows how to navigate these dynamics professionally.

Make sure that somebody is you.